Well, in Staten Island, at least.
From Cryptomundo http://www.cryptomundo.com/bigfoot-report/li-bigfoot/
I think it is believable because the area has a lot of natural woods. I took this picture of the area in 2008. That is St. Andrew's church in the background. I don't think it has changed much since 1975.On December 7, 1974, Frank Piztolato and Phillip Vivolo were in the woods near Historic Richmond Town when they "saw a black, upright ‘bear’ which roared at them." A few weeks later, on the morning of January 21, 1975, a young couple "saw Bigfoot in a church car park in the early morning" and later that night, Mrs. D. Daly was "driving late at night [and] had to brake to avoid a Bigfoot under six feet tall crossing the road from a church car park and heading for the rubbish dump and the swamp behind the church."
Though, maybe it was a bear that came over from New Jersey.